- Score each page on ten checks, 0 to 2 each, for a total out of 20.
- Use four quick tests: the stranger test, the swap test, the so what test and the read aloud test.
- Fix in order: clarity, then audience, then proof, then next step, then tone.
- Audit five pages first: home, one product or service page, pricing, your main landing page and contact or demo.
- The score is our own rule of thumb, not an industry benchmark. Use it to compare your pages and find the weak ones.
The short answer
To audit your website copy, score each key page on ten checks, from 0 to 2 each: clarity, audience, problem, value, specifics, proof, objections, next step, plain words and honesty. A page under 12 needs a rewrite. A page from 12 to 16 needs fixes to its lowest scores. Above that, leave it alone and move on. Fix clarity first, because no other improvement helps a reader who does not know what you do.
These bands are our own rule of thumb, not an industry benchmark. Use them to compare your own pages.
Pick the pages and the people
Start with five pages: home, your main product or service page, pricing, your main landing page, and contact or demo. Print them or put them in one document, without the design. Copy that only works with the picture beside it is worth finding out about.
Score alone first, and then ask someone outside the company to do it. People inside the company know what the words mean, which is the exact problem. A customer or a friend in a different job is better than your marketing team here.
The scorecard
Score each row: 0 means missing or wrong, 1 means partly there, 2 means clear.
| Check | Question | A 2 looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity | Can a stranger say what you do after the first screen? | Names the thing you sell in plain words |
| Audience | Is it clear who this is for? | A reader can rule themselves in or out |
| Problem | Does it name a problem the reader has? | In words a customer really uses |
| Value | Is the value stated as an outcome? | What changes for them, not only features |
| Specifics | Are there details a rival could not copy? | Real process, real limits, real names |
| Proof | Does each main claim have evidence near it? | Named quotes, real work, checkable facts |
| Objections | Does it answer the reason someone would not buy? | Price, risk, time and effort are covered |
| Next step | Is one next step obvious? | The button says what happens |
| Plain words | Could a new hire read it aloud without stumbling? | Short sentences, no jargon |
| Honesty | Could you defend every claim if asked? | No invented numbers, no empty superlatives |
Four tests that make scoring easy
- The stranger test. Show the first screen for a few seconds, hide it, and ask: what does this company do, and who for? Write down the exact words they use. This scores clarity and audience.
- The swap test. Put a rival's logo on your page. If nothing reads as false, your copy has no specifics. This scores specifics.
- The so what test. After each claim, ask "so what?" until you reach something the reader cares about. If you run out of answers, the claim is filler. This scores value.
- The read aloud test. Read the page aloud to a colleague. Mark each place you stumble, or would not say this to a customer. This scores plain words.
Worked example
An invented line from an invented company.
| Before | After | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| The all-in-one platform for modern teams | Payroll and leave tracking for restaurants with 5 to 50 staff | Clarity and audience |
| Save time with powerful automation | Rotas turn into payslips, so month end stops taking your weekend | Value and specifics |
| Trusted by leading brands | One named customer quote, with their role | Proof |
| Learn more | See a sample payslip | Next step |
The changes are small, but the after column says something a rival could not copy without changing its business.
How to read your score
| Score | Meaning | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 11 | The reader has to work too hard | Rewrite, starting from the message |
| 12 to 16 | Sound, with a few weak spots | Fix the rows that scored 0, then the 1s |
| 17 to 20 | Doing its job | Leave it, and spend time elsewhere |
A total can hide a bad problem, so read it with one rule: a 0 on clarity or honesty means fix it now, whatever the total says. Also compare across pages. A strong home page and a weak pricing page tell you exactly where to work.
The order to fix things
- Honesty. Remove or back up anything you could not defend.
- Clarity and audience. Rewrite the first screen. Our guide to reviewing your hero section goes deeper.
- Problem and value. Make the first third of the page about the reader.
- Proof and objections. Put evidence next to each claim.
- Next step. Match the button to what happens after the click.
- Specifics and plain words. Do these last, as polish, once the structure is right.
If the problem is the page structure and not the words, see how we design landing pages. If your demo or contact page scored lowest, start with fixing that page.
What we changed on our own site
We made these kinds of changes to our own copy. Our site used to lead with what we do and which tools we use. It now opens with the client's problem and what comes after launch: tracking, CMS, integrations, SEO, speed, QA and support.
We also softened or removed claims like "rankings kept" and "fastest", because a claim like that is hard to promise on every project. Those lines sounded strong, but they would fail the honesty row. Cutting a claim you cannot defend is usually the quickest gain on the whole scorecard.
Common mistakes
- Scoring your own writing and stopping there. You know what you meant. A stranger does not.
- Rewriting everything at once. Fix the five main pages first, and carry the new message outward.
- Changing words to fix a positioning problem. If the team cannot agree who you are for, better sentences will not settle it.
- Treating the score as a grade. The total is only there to point you at the weak rows. A team that argues over one point has missed the job, which is to fix what the reader cannot follow.
- Fixing the words and ignoring the source. The best lines usually come from sales calls and customer emails. Read those before you write.
What to do next
Score your home page now. It takes about ten minutes, and the lowest row is your next task. Then run the stranger test with one person outside the company.
If you want help with the rewrite, see our strategy and copywriting work, or send us the page and we will tell you which row we would fix first.
Terms used: Core Web Vitals, AEO



