FREEFirst project with us? Your landing page design is on the house.See the offer

Process

The website audit checklist

A practical website audit checklist: indexing, SEO, speed, content, conversion, accessibility, tracking and security, and how to turn findings into a plan.

By Abdul QuadirUpdated 2026-11-156 min read
TL;DR
  • A website audit tells you what is broken, what is holding you back, and what to fix first.
  • Check in this order: goals, tracking, indexing, SEO, speed, content, conversion, accessibility, security.
  • Use free tools: Search Console, GA4, PageSpeed Insights and a site crawler.
  • The output should be a short ranked list with owners, not a long report that nobody reads.
  • Most sites do not need a rebuild. Many gains come from fixing a few important pages.

The short answer

A website audit is a structured review of how your site performs against its goals. You check tracking, indexing, SEO, speed, content, conversion, accessibility and security, then rank what you find by impact and effort. A small site can be audited in a few focused days. The value is not in the list of problems. It is in deciding which few to fix first.

Before you start

Write down three things:

  • The goal of the site. Demos, signups, sales, or something else?
  • Your key pages. The handful that bring in traffic or leads.
  • Your questions. For example, "Why did traffic fall?" or "Why do visitors not convert?"

You will need access to Search Console, GA4, your CMS, and a crawler. Then use PageSpeed Insights for speed. A spreadsheet with one row per issue is all the software you need.

1. Tracking: can you trust your numbers?

Check this first, because every later decision relies on it.

  • Is analytics on every page, and only once?
  • Are key events firing, such as form submits and booked calls? Test them yourself.
  • Do form leads arrive in the CRM with their source?
  • Is your own team's traffic filtered out?
  • Does tracking respect your cookie consent choices?
  • Are there old tags in Tag Manager that nobody remembers?

2. Indexing: can search engines find you?

  • Check the page indexing report in Search Console. Why are pages excluded?
  • Does robots.txt block anything it should not? Include AI crawlers in your review.
  • Is there a stray noindex on an important page? This is common after a launch.
  • Does the sitemap list only live, canonical pages?
  • Do http, https, www and non-www all reach a single version of the site?
  • Do you have redirect chains or broken internal links? A crawler shows them.
  • Do you have a working 404 page?

3. On-page SEO

  • Does each page have a unique title and description?
  • Does each page have one clear H1, with a sensible heading order?
  • Do your canonical tags point to the right pages?
  • Do important pages get internal links? Find orphan pages with no links in.
  • Is schema valid, and does it match what is on the page?
  • Are several pages competing for the same search? Merge them or give each one a clear role.

Webflow users can also run through our Webflow SEO checklist.

4. Speed and page experience

  • Test your key templates, not just the homepage, on mobile.
  • Look at Core Web Vitals field data in Search Console and PageSpeed Insights, when available. Field data comes from real visitors.
  • Check the usual causes: large images, too many fonts, heavy third-party scripts and large videos.
  • Check for layout shift, such as images without dimensions or banners that push content down.
  • Use a real phone. Tap through it.

Fixes for Webflow sites are in Webflow site speed and Core Web Vitals on Webflow.

5. Content

  • Sort pages by traffic over the past year. What has fallen?
  • Is anything out of date, such as prices, features, screenshots, team members or dates?
  • Which pages get no traffic and serve no purpose? Update, merge or remove them, with redirects where needed.
  • Do pages answer real questions directly? See What is AEO?
  • Are author names and real expertise visible? See E-E-A-T.
  • Are there gaps? Compare pages against questions from sales calls.

6. Conversion

  • Can a stranger say what you do within a few seconds of landing on the homepage?
  • Does every key page have one clear next step?
  • Is each form as short as it can be? Does it work on a phone?
  • Have you sent a test through each form this month?
  • Is there real proof near the decision points?
  • Are pricing and process clear, or at least explained?
  • Where do people drop off? Check your analytics paths.

For more, see how we design landing pages that convert and CRO.

7. Accessibility

  • Run a Lighthouse or axe scan on your key templates.
  • Tab through key pages with a keyboard. Can you see the focus at all times?
  • Check text contrast, form labels, alt text and heading order.
  • Does motion respect the reduced motion setting?

A scan does not catch everything, and this does not replace a specialist audit. See WCAG for the standard.

8. Security, privacy and ownership

  • Is SSL valid on all versions of the domain?
  • Are plugins and tools up to date, if your platform has them?
  • Do leavers still have access? Check the CMS, domain, analytics and DNS.
  • Who owns the domain account? It should be your company, not a former contractor.
  • Does your consent banner match what the site actually loads?
  • Are the privacy policy and cookie list up to date? Check with your adviser.
  • Are there backups, and has anyone tried restoring one?

9. AI search readiness

  • Is important content in the HTML as text?
  • Have you decided whether to allow AI crawlers?
  • Are your company facts the same on your site, review sites and directories?
  • Is there an honest comparison or how-it-works page for the questions buyers ask?

This builds on the items above. See how to get cited by ChatGPT and Perplexity.

Turning findings into a plan

For each issue, note the page, the problem, the fix, the impact and the effort. Then sort into three groups:

  • Fix now. Broken forms, stray noindex tags, bad tracking. Small effort, big risk.
  • Plan next. Rewriting key pages, speed work on main templates, redirect clean-up.
  • Maybe later. Nice to have, little impact. It is fine to leave these.

Name one owner per item and pick a date. Then run a smaller check every few months, since sites drift. A care plan can cover some of this.

When an audit points to a rebuild

Most audits end with fixes, not a rebuild. Consider a bigger change only when the same limits keep coming back: the platform blocks what you need, each change is slow and risky, or the design no longer fits the business. If you get there, read website redesign cost and timeline and redesigning without losing SEO.

What to do next

Copy this list and start with tracking and indexing. They take the least time and have the most risk. If you want an outside view, send us your site and your goals, and see SEO and AEO or Webflow SEO. An audit shows what to improve. It cannot promise results on its own.

Abdul Quadir
Abdul QuadirFounder of Kookies. Builds Webflow and Astro sites for startups and growing teams.

Terms used: Page experience, Indexing

FAQs

Questions
people ask.

Abdul Quadir
Still have a question?Ask us directly. We reply within a day.
Book a callPick a timehello@kookies.io

A structured review of how a site performs against its goals, covering tracking, indexing, SEO, speed, content, conversion, accessibility and security.

It depends on size. A small site can be reviewed in a few focused days. Large sites take longer and may need sampling by template.

A light check every few months and a fuller one about once a year is a sensible start. Also audit after any big change.

Search Console, GA4, PageSpeed Insights and a site crawler cover most of it. Lighthouse or axe help with accessibility scans.

Anything that blocks leads or indexing: broken forms, stray noindex tags, bad tracking. Then work through key pages.

Usually not. Many gains come from fixing important pages. Consider a rebuild only if the same limits keep coming back.

Your turn

Let's kook
what you krave.

Hi Kookies, I need a built on . I'd love to launch . Reach me at
or book a callSent. We reply within one working day.